The ad is the targeting now.
If your ads dropped off over the last year or two, it wasn't you.
Put your thumb over the profile photo on one of your ads.
Could one of your past vendors tell it was yours?
If the answer's no, keep reading. Because that's most of the reason your ads haven't felt the same.
What changed
From what I'm seeing, Meta now decides who sees an ad mostly on how good the ad is, not who you target. The targeting boxes are still there. They just matter a lot less. Meta reads the ad, watches who stops on it, and goes and finds more people like them.
It's the biggest shift I've seen in nine years of doing this. And it was well overdue.
Why your ads dipped
If your ads felt strong early on and slipped over the last year or so, you're not imagining it.
The lead gen agencies flooded the feed with the same ad. Stock kitchen. Little house emoji. "What's your home worth?" in bold over a suburb name. Hundreds of agents, one template.
Meta couldn't tell you apart from them. So it lumped you all in together, and you ended up fighting every gimmicky ad in your area for the same owners.
Nothing you did wrong.
If your ad could belong to any agent, Meta treats it like it does.
The squeeze
Now Meta's squeezing that stuff out. In my experience, cheap, samey ads are getting shown less and costing more. The ones getting through look and sound like a real agent.
That's the opening. For the first time in years, being yourself is the cheapest way to be seen.
What counts as content
You don't need a film crew. Most of what works is stuff you already do:
- A 30-second walk-through on your phone, talking like you would at the open.
- The story of a street you've sold on. Who bought, why, what surprised you.
- A straight opinion on what's happening in your market, said the way you'd say it at a barbecue.
- Your face. Your voice. Your words.
The ad is the targeting now. And the ad should be you, not a stock photo of a key.
The test
Before your next ad goes out, do the thumb test. Cover the profile photo. If a past vendor couldn't pick it as yours, it's not finished.
Flick me your latest ad and I'll tell you straight whether your vendors would pick it.
Jordan
Got a better answer? Flick me an email.
Email Jordan ↗Further reading
What are they waiting for?
Most agents have never had to wait. Most owners are about to make them.
4 min readOne suburb, three ads.
What I'd put in front of homeowners in one suburb this summer, and why.
6 min readPatience.
Agents spent the boom years selling urgency. This market is asking for patience, and most of them never learnt it.
9 min read